updated March 17, 2023
Several years ago, Dim Sum, above, my canvas for an ebook cover, was my Sunday Stitching project. I enjoyed stitching it and I love it so much I used it every day for years.
But I found that I modified several stitches in order to make the stitch pattern look symmetrical.
Here’s the problem. There are many stitches that are essentially squares or rectangles. When you stitch a block of them, they line up in a grid. If they are both square and crossed, such as Smyrna Cross, you not only have the grid of the whole stitch, you have the repetition of the top stitch of the cross.
I didn’t want this to look so rigid and matchy, so I came up with some simple ways to vary square stitches so that the grid is either less obvious by breaking the rigid grid.
Make a checked stitch. By alternating one stitch with blocks of Tent Stitch, the grid becomes less clear. The smaller grain of the Tent Stitches visually makes the grid less obvious. You could also do this with any square or rectangular stitch or group of stitches.
Alternate the top stitch of a Smyrna Cross. While this keeps the grid, the second aspect. the top stitch of the cross, is broken. You can do this in a couple of ways. The more subtle one is to alternate the horizontal with the vertical stitch with the Upright Cross on top. A more obvious check is made if you alternate between the Upright and Diagonal Crosses on top.
Frame rows of stitches, but only in one direction. If you put a Tent Stitch border around each stitch or group of stitches, you just get another grid. But if you add less framing by doing it only in one direction AND by doing it every few rows, you get a subtle stripe, not a grid.
Offset each row. This is probably my favorite way to break up a grid. It looks harder to do than it is. Just start each row one stitch to the right or left (be consistent in the direction of change) from the previous row. I love this look. It keeps the blocky look of the stitch intact, but breaks up the grid.
Try one or more of these ideas the next time your box or square cross stitch looks too rigid.
About Janet M Perry
Janet Perry is the Internet's leading authority on needlepoint. She designs, teaches and writes, getting raves from her fans for her innovative techniques, extensive knowledge and generous teaching style. A leading writer of stitch guides, she blogs here and lives on an island in the northeast corner of the SF Bay with her family
Janet Gebow says
Dear Janet,
I enjoy reading your blog, for not only are you a great stitcher, you are committed to teaching and enhancing stitching for all your readers.
The other day, while getting side tracked on my Nook, I did a quick search to see what Wikipedia said about needlepoint. It was pathetic. I do not know who wrote and illustrated this posting, but whoever it was described needlepointing as the most boring of pursuits. The information might have been relevant 40 years ago, but it is not at all relevant to the way most creative needlepoint is done today.
It would be great if you, and perhaps other teachers with authority could rewrite this posting and illustrate it with photos of all the creative things that are being stitched now. Perhaps providing a link to the ANG site in general, and in particular to the section, “What is Needlepoint,” would be helpful.
I know your time is valuable, and so this may not be a priority, but wanted to put the idea before you.
Thanks again for your blog,
Janet Gebow
Janet Perry says
Great idea, I’ll take a look.
Keep Stitching,
Janet